You want to know how to tie a scarf around your neck, a men’s neck scarf. Okay, fair enough, that’s literally what you just searched for. But let me ask you one question, right before we start looking up Parisian knots or however the hell they’re supposed to be tied. Have you measured the scarf you want to tie? I’ll bet you haven’t because I’ll also bet that that’s the actual problem, not how you’re tying it. I spent three winters, maybe four blaming myself for badly tied scarves when the scarf itself was actually the wrong length for what I wanted to do with it.
Nobody tells you about that bit.
Nobody. They all skip straight to the folding process itself.
The length nobody mentions
I struggled with this for far too long, and what I got wrong was this: I had a scarf, a nice grey merino scarf, around 150cm long. It drove me mad because no matter how I tied it, every knot looked bunchy and stupid. Like I’d tied it too tight or done it awkwardly in a doorway because, to be honest, I usually had. What it didn’t occur to me until much, much later was that 150cm was never going to play nicely with any knots that actually wrapped more than once. If you want that double wrap, where it loops around your neck twice and still has enough hanging down to drape properly you need closer to 180cm. Throw on a larger frame or try and fit it under a bulky winter coat and you want to be aiming nearer 200cm.
Until it’s actually that long, you’re not tying it, you’re just shoving it around and hoping the ends don’t hang too short. I learned that lesson properly on a day that, teeth silently gritted, I still think about. It was one of those “fresh breeze with sunny intervals” kind of days the weather forecast is so abominably useless at predicting. It ended up being -2 degrees with a wind that felt like it hated me personally. I had my short scarf on, looping it once as always, but because it wasn’t long enough it kept flipping loose every time I turned my head. In a school hallway this is approximately every four seconds. By lunchtime I’d accepted defeat and just stuffed it in my coat like some Dickens-era overdramatic neck rag.
One of my year tens asked if I was dressed as a Victorian chimney sweep. He meant insultingly. He was also not wrong, so I bought a new scarf that week. Believe me when I say I learned that lesson.
You don’t need maths degrees to work this bit out, you just don’t know until you’ve been buying scarves for a decade like I have. Basically, your scarf needs to be long enough to wrap around your neck twice, with enough spare for the knot you want to tie, and with enough still hanging down your front to look intentional as opposed to accidental. If you only ever intend to wear it as that simple drape thing, one loop and let the ends hang loose on either side, then sure, you can get away with a shorter scarf, maybe as short as 140cms.
Give it any real fold whatsoever and you’re suddenly short that last few inches it needs to look nice, and that’s when you have to go out and buy a new scarf because yours doesn’t work. I check the centimetres before I bother looking at colours now. Which should tell you how embarrassing my scarf journeys have been.
You Might Also Like
The width and weight decides if it works with a coat at all
This bit probably gets skipped over even more than how long your scarf needs to be. How wide it is, and how heavy it feels when you hold it. Slim, lightweight scarves that you think look nice on their own are garbage at actually going under a real winter coat collar. They bunch up, disappear into it, and then reappear halfway down your chest. I own a lovely cashmere blend scarf, maybe 25cms wide that suffers this problem and proudly. Bought it thinking it’d be versatile. Can’t wear it with anything bulky because it just gets lost.
The stuff that works under a coat is wider than that, 30cms minimum, and with actual weight to it. I can’t stress this enough; your scarf needs some heft. A lightweight scarf might work aesthetically by itself but as soon as you put a coat over it, the coat wins and your scarf loses. Gets pushed out of the way, draped oddly, you look like you’ve forgotten to wear it.
Things with heft actually stay on top of your coat collar.
The thing-weight does that took me even longer to realise is how it impacts the knot you tie as well.
A thick, heavy scarf keeps its knot strong; it doesn’t slip about all day. Throw a lightweight scarf on and that knot turns into an anxiety-inducing proposal by lunchtime because it’s moved an inch down your neck. You find yourself constantly retying it like a toddler that can’t keep their shoelaces done.
Mid-re-tie in the staff room is not an attractive look for anyone, no matter how artsy that knot might look on YouTube. So before you go looking for tying instructions, make sure you know what coat your scarf actually needs to fit under first. That’s what decides the width and weight your scarf needs long before you start worrying about which knot will look Instagram-worthy.
If you’ve got the length right for the knot you want to tie and you’ve picked the width and weight to suit the coat you actually wear then tying it becomes just about academic. Loads of the knots people wanna search tutorials for are simple enough that most grown humans could do them blindfold in thirty seconds if they’ve got a scarf of the right length. The tutorials aren’t lying to you. Your scarf drawer is.
