Top Picks
San Nicola Navy Penny Loafer
RYAN’S PICK SANTORO MILANSan Nicola Navy Penny Loafer
£59.99 SANTORO MILAN
San Mauro Navy loafer
ARJUN’S PICK SANTORO MILANSan Mauro Navy loafer
£59.99 SANTORO MILAN
San Mauro Tan loafer
OLLIE’S PICK SANTORO MILANSan Mauro Tan loafer
£59.99 SANTORO MILAN
G. H. Bass Panama Horse Bit Lincoln Saddle Bar Penny Loafers
MARCUS’ PICK COESG. H. Bass Panama Horse Bit Lincoln Saddle Bar Penny Loafers
£165.00 COES
Chie Mihara Flat shoes
TOM’S PICK DRESTIGEChie Mihara Flat shoes
£318.60 DRESTIGE
How we pick

Every collection here starts with a pile of products and ends with a short list chosen by real men. For rubber sole leather loafers, that was Ryan, Arjun, Ollie, Marcus and Tom. They looked at cut, fabric, reviews where there were any and, honestly, whether they'd actually put it on this weekend. Things that look sharp on a model and baggy on everyone else tend to get cut. The full list underneath is everything that matched, from lots of different shops, so you can still have a proper browse.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

More like this

See all in Rubber Sole Shoes →
Rubber Sole Formal Shoes You Can Walk All Day InRubber Sole ShoesRubber Sole Formal Shoes You Can Walk All Day InRubber Sole Shoes You’ll Wear More Than You ThinkRubber Sole ShoesRubber Sole Shoes You’ll Wear More Than You ThinkWhite Rubber Sole Shoes Hunted Down So You Don’t Have ToRubber Sole ShoesWhite Rubber Sole Shoes Hunted Down So You Don’t Have ToRubber Sole Cap Toe Shoes That Get Better With AgeRubber Sole ShoesRubber Sole Cap Toe Shoes That Get Better With AgeBlack Rubber Sole Shoes You’ll Keep for YearsRubber Sole ShoesBlack Rubber Sole Shoes You’ll Keep for YearsRubber Sole Loafers That Go With Jeans and ChinosRubber Sole ShoesRubber Sole Loafers That Go With Jeans and Chinos