Nothing here yet.
The question I get most is whether a trench coat works if you're not heading into an office or out for dinner somewhere smart, and the answer is yes, but only if you stop treating it like a costume. It's a coat, not a statement about your personality. Worn with normal clothes underneath, it just looks like a bloke who owns a good coat.
Where it goes wrong is when people pair it with anything too busy underneath, big logos, bright trainers, a rucksack slung over one shoulder like you're dashing for a train. The coat has a clean, architectural shape, belt, lapels, the lot, and it fights with clutter. Trainers in general are a struggle unless they're plain and low profile. Chunky boots look wrong too, there's a weight mismatch, the coat wants something with a bit of polish or at least a clean leather sole underneath it, even if that's just a decent pair of derbies or clean minimal trainers rather than anything formal.
The difference between a trench that's worth having and one that'll annoy you by November shows up in the hand before it shows up anywhere else. Pick it up and feel the weight, a proper cotton gabardine has a dry, slightly waxy stiffness to it, it holds its shape off the body rather than slumping. Cheap versions feel floppy and thin, more like a shower mac that's lost its nerve. Check the collar and lapels sit with some structure rather than curling, look at the stitching along the storm flap and the belt loops, and give the buttons a tug, horn or proper metal ones feel solid, plastic ones feel like they're on a countdown to falling off in a pocket somewhere.
On colour, I'd steer towards the classic stone or camel shades before anything else, they go with nearly everything you already own and they don't date the way a fashion colour will in three years. Navy is a close second and slightly easier if you wear a lot of black. Proper black trenches look sharp but they're less forgiving, they show creasing and dust in a way the lighter shades don't, so I'd only go there once you're sure you'll wear it enough to justify the upkeep.
The bit that makes a good one a genuine pleasure, though, is the belt. Not just that it's there, but that it has a proper buckle you can cinch tight without it slipping loose by lunchtime, and a loop sewn in at the back so you're not fishing for the tail of it every time you take the coat off on a train.
Nothing here yet.