Nothing here yet.
The mistake is treating smart casual shoes as a compromise between two proper pairs, something that's a bit of a trainer and a bit of a brogue and ends up neither. You end up with a shoe that looks like it's apologising for itself, too formal for the jeans, too casual for the collar. The whole point is that it should look deliberate, not like you couldn't decide what you were going for that morning.
What separates a good pair from a disappointing one comes down to the same things every time. Real leather or a decent suede that takes a bit of polish and ages rather than just wearing out, a sole that's got some give in it rather than a slab of hard rubber that makes you walk like you've got cardboard strapped to your feet, and stitching you can actually see rather than a glued seam that starts lifting after a few months of normal use. Check the lining too, a cheap synthetic lining will have your feet sweating by lunchtime, and the eyelets and laces matter more than people expect, flimsy laces snap and cheap metal eyelets go tarnished looking within weeks. Where this category runs out of road is anywhere genuinely formal, a wedding, an interview at a firm that still cares about suits, or anywhere wet and horrible underfoot, most of these soles and leathers are not built for standing in driving rain for twenty minutes waiting for a bus.
Colour wise, the ones that let you get dressed without thinking too hard are a mid brown or tan leather, and a dark navy or grey suede if you want something a notch softer looking. Both go with denim, chinos, and the kind of plain knitwear most men already own, without you having to plan an outfit around the shoe itself. Pure black smart casual shoes are the one I'd be wary of, they tend to drift back towards looking like office shoes that have had a bad week, and white or very pale versions show every scuff and splash within a fortnight, which is a lot of upkeep for something you're wearing to the pub.
Where they genuinely fall apart as a choice is next to anything already shouting, chunky cargo trousers, a loud graphic shirt, or a suit that's trying to be sharp. Pair any of that with a fussy shoe and you've got two things competing for attention and neither one winning. Keep the rest of the outfit calm and let the shoe be the detail, and it holds up fine. Just don't expect it to do a job it was never built for.
Nothing here yet.