Nothing here yet.
Old money shoes are the ones doing the quiet work of making everything else look like it costs more than it did. Loafers, suede derbies, plain cap toe oxfords, the odd chukka boot in a soft brown, all built around the idea that the shoe should look like it has been owned for a decade even when it has been owned for a fortnight. The job is to anchor a smart casual outfit without shouting about it, which is a strange thing to ask of a shoe but there it is.
Where this goes wrong is pairing old money shoes with anything that is trying equally hard in a different direction. Chunky trainers energy on top, a quiet suede loafer on the bottom, and the whole outfit argues with itself. The same goes for very new, very shiny tailoring. These shoes want slightly worn in chinos, a decent jumper, a jacket with some age to the fabric, not a suit straight off the rail with the crease still showing. They also do not love being paired with sports socks, which sounds obvious until you see someone do it at a barbecue and spend the rest of the afternoon thinking about it.
Fit on these is less forgiving than people expect, because a lot of the style depends on the shoe sitting close to the foot rather than having room to spare. A cheap pair solves this by using a stiff unlined upper that never moves, so you get a shoe that looks fine in the box and then spends three wears cutting into your ankle before it gives up entirely. A good pair uses a softer leather or suede that moulds slightly over the first few wears, which means you should buy true to size rather than a half size up to compensate for stiffness, and you should expect a short break in period rather than instant comfort. Watch for toes that go tight across the widest part of your foot, because that spot does not stretch much no matter how patient you are.
In the shop, check the stitching around the welt, run a thumb along the sole to see if it flexes or just sits there like a brick, and have a proper look at the lining, because a cheap lining bunches and rubs in a way that ruins an otherwise decent looking shoe. The honest limit here is weather and distance. These are not built for a genuine downpour or a long walk across a city, and suede in particular will tell you exactly how it feels about rain within about four minutes.
If I was starting a collection from nothing, I would go for a mid brown suede over black, every time.
Nothing here yet.