Toe hanging off the end of your flip flops is a crime against summer. Honest. Don’t believe me? Stand in a room with someone doing it and watch their toes start to curl defensively up their feet when you tell them that. Because believe me, it will feel that bad when somebody calls you out on it, and trust me again because I am about to – it isn’t just comfortable at all, it looks stupid too. Nobody wants to see that.

A lady serving crisps and cakes at a Sunday car boot sale looked down at my feet without prompt or invitation and told me as much.

I hadn’t even asked for her opinion; clearly, I was looking for a decent tan belt for under a tenner, not an eternity lecture about appropriate footwear from an old woman selling sausage rolls.

The_Questions_I_Had_About_Flip_Flops_Sizing_Answered_Drawing__a17fe5f3-941e-4a79-8747-00b0d036de98_1

But she was right. Every. Single. Word.

My initial reaction was verbal diarrhoea somewhere along the lines of “who asked you, hen?” But brainwave number two, arriving thankfully about four seconds later, was that she had every right to tell me and any other filthy beggar letting their toes bleed through the end of their sandals all summer because I was doing it too. It had taken a Sunday morning birdwatcher with a keen eye and absolutely no concept of politeness to call me out on something that had been achingly obvious to anyone who wasn’t me. How had nobody said anything sooner?

Let’s get something straight about flip flop fit – every man out there is almost definitely getting it wrong in one way or another. Are you one of the many who size up for that freshly-bought-toe-room? Or maybe you go too small and end up curling your toes so you don’t slip out? You need to learn how to do it properly. And quickly.

Don’t get me wrong, flip flop fit isn’t rocket science. But it’s far too overlooked considering they’re by far the weirdest fitting item of clothing we wear all year. They don’t behave like normal shoes. Or trainers. Get them right and you’ve nailed comfortable footwear for a year of sunny weekends. Get them wrong and you’re spending the hottest months with rubbing soles and blistered toes, and who wants that?

The fit when you buy them, and why overhang is a problem

Here’s the kicker. And the bit I got wrong for far too long without realising. When you try on flip flops, you want them to sit flush with the edge of your foot. Your toes. Your heel. Flush. Full stop. I used to assume, like with normal shoes, that a “true to size” pair would have a little bit of extra room at the end. They don’t. Let me repeat that because it really is important; when you buy your flip flops, they should not have overhang at the toe.

You don’t need it. With shoes and trainers that toe space is there to allow your foot to swell throughout the day without you marching round with clenched toes. Your flip flop has no upper to contain your foot, so any part of your toes (or god forbid, heel) that aren’t sitting flat against the sole aren’t being held anywhere. They’re just… hanging over the kitchen sink, the swimming pool steps or the jaggedly gravelly hell you’ve decided to walk across in the barefoot style sandals.

Heel overhang is just as bad, but far less discussed. Having your heel flop around at the back instead of sitting tight against the base of your flip flop does two things. One, it wears down the sole on one side faster than you can probably notice until it does happen and two, it makes a horrible slapping sound with every step you take that will announce your arrival from fucking miles away.

Buy them too small though and you’ll be curled toes just as much as if they were too big. It doesn’t feel as uncomfortable at first, so you might not notice until you’re a few miles in. But those curled toes are gripping the front of your sandals for dear life because they need to. And flexing your toes like that for long periods of time isn’t natural. It’ll hurt.

Your flip flop should fit your foot perfectly from end to end when you buy them. No more, no less.

What a few wears actually does to the fit

Let’s talk about how wear affects your flip flop fit, because this is the bit nobody tells you and the bit that actually changed my thinking on the “what size should I buy” question from a simple answer to something a little more nuanced.

Flip flops stretch. The strap, whatever it’s made of – rubber? Cloth? God forbid some leather – is going to stretch with wear. Why? Because your foot is yanking it around thousands of times per wear, and as any good material will, it gives. Not by much, but it gives. A pair that felt secure and cosy on day one, perfectly flush to your foot like I advised above, will start to feel a little loose by wear three, four if you’ve been lucky. Especially if you’ve been wearing the fuck out of them every time you put them on; they’ll not have had time to stretch so much if they’ve spent the year shame-faced in the cupboard next to your drawers.

The footbed also moulds slightly to your foot. All foam does this to a degree, your weight pressing down on it forces it to compress. This sounds like a good thing and, for the most part, it is.

The_Questions_I_Had_About_Flip_Flops_Sizing_Answered_Drawing__a17fe5f3-941e-4a79-8747-00b0d036de98_2

But it does mean that the toe isn’t going to be sitting exactly as it did when you tried those flip flops on in the shop come the real wear count.

So… here’s my advice.

Buy them slight snug. Make sure they’re as flush to your foot as you possibly can without them feeling like they’re going to slide off every time you take a step. They will loosen with wear because of that strap stretching I told you about, but if they’re flush when you try them on you’ll have nowhere for them to go but too loose.

Learn this from my mistakes. I thought snug as fuck equals perfect fit equals cool. They did start to slip at the heel every time I went up a curb after about two weeks of ownership. Which, as it happens, was when the strap finally stretched enough that my foot was suddenly too far forward in the sole to stay put. Shoes that used to fit perfectly suddenly don’t? Bingo, your feet are overhanging now mate.